This is a critique of the sorts of naive tabulation of education data which we found to be prevalent in Afghanistan from 2003-2006. It argues that data is indeed crucial for effective planning to improve systems but that it is necessary to first articulate practical, actionable research questions and, then, explore them in a systematic fashion rather than "throwing everything into the soup pot". The presentation includes recommendations regarding international donors' roles vis-a-vis the host country role and specific suggestions for two high-priority Ministry of Education initiatives to improve education access and quality.